Light Mode
Dark Mode
System Mode
What would happen to the markets if the United States capped its interest rates, just as Japan did? The US 10-year Treasury yield has exceeded 5%. US Treasury Secretary Bessent wants to bring this yield down. The Treasury is buying back long-term bonds. Yet in Japan, the cost of following the same path was eventually paid through a depreciation of the yen. I will explain what happened in Japan, where the United States stands today, and what it means for the markets.
At the beginning of 2013, prices in Japan were not rising. They had been falling for years. The government asked the central bank to take more decisive action to stop prices from declining. The central bank adopted a 2% inflation target. A few months later, it dramatically expanded its government bond purchases.
Years passed, yet inflation still failed to reach 2%. In 2016, the central bank went even further and made a commitment to the markets. Under this commitment, the 10-year yield would remain around zero. Whenever yields threatened to exceed that level, the central bank would purchase bonds and push them back down.
For a long time, maintaining this commitment was not difficult because interest rates were also low around the world.
So, when did the problem begin?
The world changed in 2022. As inflation surged, the United States rapidly raised interest rates, and its 10-year Treasury yield exceeded 4%. Japan, however, refused to abandon its commitment. The central bank increased its purchases to defend the yield cap, and by the same year, it held more than half of all government bonds.
Suppressing interest rates in this way was like squeezing a balloon from one side. The squeezed area moves inward, but the balloon expands somewhere else.
Interest rates stayed in place, but the pressure shifted to the yen.
The yen fell against the US dollar to its lowest level since 1990. After a long absence, Japan intervened in the markets for the first time to support its currency. As the yen weakened, imported energy and food became even more expensive.
The central bank loosened the cap at the end of 2022 and completely abandoned it in March 2024.
Japan did not experience a debt crisis along this path. Today, its central bank no longer imposes a cap on long-term interest rates and is reducing its bond purchases.
Now, let’s look at the United States.
As US debt grows, every increase in interest rates puts greater pressure on the federal budget. In August, the Treasury increased the amount of long-term bonds it was buying back. Yields fell that day. The following day, they rose again.
In September, the Treasury increased its buybacks once more. Nevertheless, yields continued to climb and reached their highest level since 2002 in early October.
Why weren’t the buybacks enough?
Because these purchases are very small compared with the total US debt. The Treasury is also financing this money through new short-term borrowing. It is like paying off one credit card with another. The debt changes hands, but it does not decrease.
In Japan, however, the central bank purchased government bonds and could expand its purchases as much as it wanted. A central bank does not borrow money from the market to do this; it creates the money it needs.
In the United States, the Federal Reserve is not buying long-term bonds. Moreover, as short-term borrowing increases, the Treasury’s interest burden becomes more closely tied to the Fed’s interest rate.
This is why Bessent’s November 13 statement is important. He said it would be a mistake for the Fed to raise interest rates too much. In his view, an energy shock is what is driving inflation higher.
The Fed responded immediately. One of the Fed’s regional presidents said that price increases could not be explained by oil alone. Fed Chair Warsh is also opposed to the Fed suppressing interest rates through bond purchases.
In other words, there are two sides at the table. The Treasury wants to keep long-term interest rates down, while the Fed is not currently willing to follow that path.
In Japan, the process also began in 2013 with a similar call from the government to its central bank. In that case, the central bank complied.
The difference is significant. Prices were falling in Japan, whereas inflation in the United States is already above its target.
The disagreement between the Treasury and the Fed is nothing new for the United States.
In 1942, the Fed imposed a 2.5% cap on long-term interest rates to keep wartime borrowing costs low. When the war ended, the Treasury wanted the cap to remain, and it did.
Meanwhile, price controls were lifted, and prices rose by nearly 20% in a single year.
Someone holding government bonds was earning 2.5% annually. They were making money on paper but losing purchasing power when shopping.
By 1951, the Fed wanted to free itself from this restriction. The US president, however, announced that the Fed had promised to keep interest rates low.
One of the Fed’s officials leaked meeting notes to the press, demonstrating that no such promise had been made. A few weeks later, the cap was removed, and the Fed regained control over setting interest rates.
So, what do these two stories tell us?
Interest rates can be capped. But the cost of that cap does not disappear; it is transferred to the value of the currency.
In my view, the Fed’s stance will determine what happens next in the United States.
If the Fed sides with the government, interest rates will fall, but the cost will be reflected in the value of the dollar. That is what happened in Japan.
If the Fed chooses its own path, the markets will determine interest rates, and US borrowing will become more expensive. That is what happened in 1951.
During the years when interest rates were suppressed in Japan, the stock market surpassed its historical highs, while the yen weakened. If the United States follows the same path, a similar pattern could emerge in the markets. As money becomes cheaper, stocks generally rise, while the currency itself loses value.
If you hold US dollars, this story concerns you too.
The indicators to watch are clear.
The first is artificial intelligence investment.
Artificial intelligence was expected to increase productivity and bring prices down. Warsh shares this view. Yet today, the opposite is happening. Data centers are creating enormous demand for electricity, chips and construction, pushing prices higher.
According to many Fed officials, the benefits of productivity improvements will come later, while inflationary pressures have already arrived. As long as these investments continue, the likelihood of the Fed raising interest rates increases.
AI companies are also absorbing substantial liquidity from the markets.
Anthropic carried out the largest initial public offering in history this week, and investors lined up to buy shares. This money comes from the same investors who also lend to the US Treasury. The Treasury is now competing with AI companies for their capital.
I believe this situation will bring the Treasury and the Fed into even greater conflict.
The second indicator is the language chosen by the Fed.
The Fed is expected to raise interest rates in December. What matters is not just the decision itself, but the words used alongside it.
In the minutes of the October meeting, some Fed members discussed dividing bond purchases into two categories. One would involve purchases made to lower interest rates, while the other would involve purchases intended to ensure the proper functioning of the markets.
If the Fed buys long-term bonds one day, I believe it will justify the move by citing the need to ensure that markets function properly. If this language becomes more frequent in Fed statements, the door to such purchases will also open.
The third indicator is the dollar.
If the dollar loses value while the Treasury expands its buybacks, it means the cost is being transferred to the currency.
When these indicators all point in the same direction, the United States will have taken another step along Japan’s path.
Economist Milton Friedman gave this cost a name in 1974.
Inflation is the only tax that can be imposed without passing a law.
This is my personal analysis. I am following developments closely. I will keep you informed.
Kaynak: Penguin X (@ThePenguinBTC)